Compare

Concrete, Pavers or Timber: Choose by How You Will Use It

Most comparisons start from the materials. Start from what will actually sit on the thing and stand on it, and the choice narrows a lot faster. Written by people who lay only one of these three, and who will say when your garden is asking for another.

Updated September 2026 · Pleasant Prairie Concrete

Say it plainly first: we pour concrete. We do not lay pavers and we do not build decks, so weigh the paragraphs below accordingly - and notice that several of them send you elsewhere. A comparison that finds for its author in every case is not a comparison. If the answer does come out as concrete, our page on a concrete patio in Pleasant Prairie, WI covers what we build and how to book a site visit.

The usual way to run this argument is material by material, which produces a table and no decision. A better order is to ask what the space is for, because the intended use rules options out far more decisively than the material specifications ever do.

If it is a table, chairs and people sitting

This is most patios, and it is the case where all three genuinely work.

The thing that matters here is flatness held over time, because a table that rocks is the single most reliable source of low-grade annoyance in a back garden. A poured slab starts flat and stays flat, with its movement channelled into joints somebody cut on purpose. Pavers start flat and drift, unit by unit, as the ground below freezes and thaws, which is why re-levelling recurs. A deck starts flat and stays flat as long as its structure does.

If the ground is level and you want to stop thinking about it, concrete. If you want the look of individual units and do not mind returning to it, pavers. Both are defensible.

If it is a grill, a fire pit or anything genuinely heavy

Here the field narrows. A poured slab does not char, does not shift under a concentrated load, and does not need a protective layer under an appliance. That combination is difficult for the other two to match.

Timber near sustained heat needs clearances and protection, which is manageable but is a design constraint rather than an afterthought. Pavers handle the heat without complaint, but the units carrying a heavy item will tend to bed in unevenly over a few seasons, and levelling them again means moving the heavy item.

If an outdoor kitchen or a fire feature is part of the plan, say so before anybody quotes. What sits on a surface changes what has to be underneath it.

If it is bare feet and small children

This one splits, and not the way people expect.

Timber is kindest underfoot at the edges of the season and stays cooler in strong sun. That is a real advantage and it is the strongest argument for a deck on flat ground.

Against it: children fall, and what matters more than surface temperature is that the surface is continuous and level, with no gaps to catch a toe and no unit standing proud of its neighbour. A slab is one piece by definition. That is the case for concrete here, and a lighter finish keeps it comfortable through most of a Wisconsin summer.

If it is a hot tub

A hot tub full of water and people is a heavy, concentrated, permanent load, and it is the one use that genuinely dictates the answer: a poured slab, sized and built for that load from the start.

A deck can carry one where it was designed to, and that design has to happen before the first post goes in rather than after the tub is delivered. Pavers are the weakest of the three under this kind of point load, because the loading finds the individual units and they settle independently.

Tell whoever is quoting exactly where the tub is going and how big it is. This is the item most often mentioned after the surface is already down, and it is the most expensive one to add late.

The ground still gets a veto

Everything above assumes the ground will allow it. Go and look at the fall between your back door and where you want to sit.

If the garden drops away noticeably, holding a solid surface at door level means either bringing in and consolidating a serious quantity of fill, or stepping down from the threshold and giving up the idea that the seating sits level with the kitchen. Beyond a certain fall, a raised structure stops being a preference and becomes the correct way to build there, whatever the intended use.

So run the use question first, then walk the ground, and let the ground overrule you if it wants to. It usually knows.

What each one asks of you afterwards

• Concrete. No annual task. Keep chemicals off it, particularly in its first winter, and revisit a sealer every few seasons. The reasoning behind the first-winter rule, and why the products sold as gentle are the wrong ones, is in our patio budgeting guide.
• Pavers. Re-levelling and re-sanding on a cycle the soil sets, plus weeds in the joints. Offset by the ability to lift and reset any part of it indefinitely.
• Timber. Cleaning and refinishing on a schedule you can predict, and boards eventually. Predictability is worth something.